I dont think it would be wren, I mean he never even met or knew Ali before Pilot. It's not like He secretly dated Melissa with Ian. Plus his only regrets are when he Cheated on Melissa with Spencer and Kissed Hanna in Radley.
If Mona is -A, Then why would she throw herself in the back of a car, Pale and barely breathing? And if she is Alive, She'd be copying Ian.
Toby wanted to join the -A team to protect spencer. And he clearly said that he wouldn't want to hear anymore theories about Marion that came out of -A's Mouth.
Ezra joined the -A team because he wanted Answers about Ali and probably to throw A of the track.
I don't really believe that Aria is on the -A team. The only thing that she would be still angry about is when Byron and Meredith were making out in his Car and Ali was threatening Aria that if she didn't tell her Mother, Someone else would ( I presume Mona who was the current -A at that time or Alison). Ali probably didn't want Aria to be hurt.
Why would CeCe be -A? She left for france so she wouldn't have to face the charges for Wilden's murder. She practically saved Ashley and Hanna & Alison because of the way Wilden treated all of them, especially Hanna's Mom. If i were her, I wouldn't bring my stinky ass back to rosewood because then they will easily find her. Duh
PAIGE IS NOT -A!!! She would protect emily from any harm, including Alison. Plus how is she the Black widow????????? That women is like Tiny AF! Paig s practically 1.5 times bigger than that bitch!
Sydney is nearly Impossible. Sorry Guys, unless you have a theory that she Dated Alison or hated her when she was in Georgia, I don't see a connection with Ali and the Girls, Besides Emily and how she helped Jenna into the eye thignymhbsbif. Damn She makes a great Tammin sursok.
Here is my List of Current -A's:
1. Maya: Maya's Body was never really Shown. Alison's Body was never shown and Look at that! She's Freaking Alive! I still need to do more research on Maya Though, How is she a link to alison and why did she really come to rosewood, besides the fact of running for lyndon/"Nate".
2. Jenna: Why did Jenna Suddenly appear to be not wearing her Gucci Glasses? And who was she talking to? It could be possible it was Ali, But i believe she is just trying to hurt Alison more by pretending to be friends with her...
I know it's pretty small but i'll eventually grow more suspects...
I can near guarantee its NOT sydney..just because theres a quote from marlene about it on the black widow wikia page. For a while, I was thinking it could be Jenna or her twin just because I saw some picture of her and her hair looked a lot like the hair of the person who killed Mona. Except obviously blonde. Judging just by hair, its Ali, a twin (which opens up many more suspects), or someone with a wig. Just putting some facts together, in that wikia I was talking about, Marlene had said that A was seen in s4 and introduced in s5. So it could be someone we already know or someone not yet introduced. But from s4, we were never told that anyone had a twin. Maybe it was just a sister. To me, Marion being a part of this somehow makes a lot of sense. She has a strong resemblance to Mrs. Dilaurentis.
but marlene also clarified that A was seen in the pilot, along with mona. so tha means it ia either Jenna or Maya. The possibilities are endless but thats who im sticking with for now
correct me if i'm wrong, but Marlene also said that A would appear both in the pilot and the season 3 premiere. it can't be Mona because we already knew that Mona was A by the season 2 finale. And maya's body was found on the season 2 finale as well. that leaves everybody else. :D
Ok i have a new theory on who killed mona!
I have a feeling it's Cindy or Mindy or Both of them, because they both wore blonde wigs to distract Paige, Emily, Aria and Lucas from Ali's escape in the christmas ep. It wasn't clarified that she was informed of both of them transitioned to ali's side. Paige informed Hanna, Aria and Spencer at the brew, seconds before Spencer was charged for the murder of bethany. And Mona did surely seem shocked seeing the identity of the murderer(s). we know that Both of them perfected how ali moved and walked as it was seen in 5x13. Those wigs look kind off indentical to the original wig, especially when mindy wore the alison wig. Ali could've lied to Hanna and may have been with the twins, because there were 3 people on mona's property on thanksgiving. Mona's assailant, A's lookout and Mona's possible distractor or the person who walks her stairs and unlocks her front door. I presume that there were cameras in her room, since she probably put camera's around the house because she knew she will not survive any way before graduation. I think these are the events of mona's assasination:
1. Mona and Leona exhange their final goodbye. Behind her, the first hoodie hides behind a bush, making a small noise that makes mona have a confused and scared look. She then rushes to the front door and closes it, looking into the window one last time before securely locking the door.
2. The first hoodie gestures for the second hoodie to unlock the door. They unlock the door and they step inside, they leave the door for the assailant to come in and start walking up the stairs, taking the hood of showing either ali's hair or a wig, maybe the exact wig mindy wore as her ali disguise in 5x13. Then the assailant pushes the doornob and enters. [note:Notice how the doornob is just like the one in the telephone booth in the mansion where Hanna was kept in until Miranda Collins frees her? interesting]
3. While mona gets the message from Hanna ( or is it one lf the hoodies? ) Both the hoodies wait outside. While mona calls aria, Maybe theyre getting ready to plot the murder. As mona says her final words, the door opens, revealing someone who she trusts. Im not sure that she was informed by paige that the twins have converted to Ali's army, so maybe it's Cindy or mindy. They either fight or have an argument over the evidence of alison being A or killing bethany.
4. As they are fighting, maybe Mona does not agree to hand over the evidence, then her assailant manages to kill her. Keep in mind they are able to throw Mona like she's a ragdoll. Then one of the hoodies texts alison (as cyrus) to meet her near a park next to Mona's Home.
5. Since Toby said that the knife looked exactly like his father's, Maybe they got a exact copy and used it to kill mona, throwing the liars off thinking that is was the original copy. So once Mona is slipping away from life, they cut her left wrist and draw the blood out to paint the -A on her left cheek. Also, when Alison finally arrives to meet "Cyrus" , Mona Screams for one last time, Making Ali realize that this was a trap.
Just to confirm, what if the assailant was male? Holbrook maybe? Maybe that's why he never appeared in 5x15 because he knew that Hanna would visit Ali and is hiding with his Father and Brother. He could've placd the intestine teddy in Hanna's Car, and placed the Note in ali's scrubs.
So i think these are The three hoodies.( Random Order, They could have been Distractor or the Assailant.)
1. Cindy / Mindy / Holbrook
3. Cindy / Mindy / -A
I hope you like this theor ;D
She opened her window blinds to let some light in, but Courtney noticed her twin hiding right by the window with a camera. She ignored her (though was secretly terrified that her friends would see her) and argued with Spencer before storming out. Spencer followed her to the edge of the Hastings property and they continued their argument. After Spencer shoved her lightly to the ground, Courtney, in anger, dropped the (false) bombshell that she was seeing Ian and another (true) bombshell that she convinced him to kiss Spencer. As she continued to taunt her friend, Spencer shoved her into the stone wall of the Hastings property. Courtney recovered quickly but noticed someone up ahead in her own backyard. Knowing that it was Alison, she ran off and ignored Spencer, who would be the last Liar to see her alive. When Courtney runs into the woods, Alison appeared and began threatening and taunting Courtney. Then the two girls began wrestling on the ground. Courtney said that all she wanted was for the two of them to be sisters and Ali says that she wants to kill Courtney, but she can't. At that moment Ian Thomas came, then Alison pushed her into the hole for the gazebo. She recognized both voices, her sister's and the unknown person's (it is not said in the book who the unknown person is). Courtney makes speculations as to who the unknown person is, but the identity of this person is not revealed. Alison's plan A was to make Courtney switch back places with her, but when that didn't work, she switched to plan B. Plan B was to kill Courtney and replace her. Alison and her accomplice throw Courtney into the hole and pile a lot of dirt on Courtney's body, unaware that she was still alive. Alison slips back inside, hoping that her parents won't see her, but they do. At first they call her out as Courtney, but she argues it and they let her go upstairs. Alison thinks she has won, but in the morning her mother questions her about the where-abouts of Courtney-as-Ali and notices that Alison is not wearing the Jenna thing bracelet or the A-for-Ali ring. Jessica DiLaurentis freaks out thinking that Ali-as-Courtney has donesomething horrible to her twin. Alison is taken back to the Preserve at Addison-Stevens. As they drive away, Ali sees Courtney's best friends and blames them for her problems. In her mind, if they hadn't been in the backyard that day, she wouldn't have been mistaken as Courtney and taken to the Preserve at Addison-Stevens. She plans to get revenge on them (thus the idea of "A" is born).
Idk who -A is I don't actually care, I mean I want to know but whoever it is I don't like or hate them more then I already do. Hanna's my favorite character with Mona in second so I like Mona pretty much bcuz she was -A for a point in time. And if Hanna's -A her cred in my eyes will actually go up!
I hope it is him because if the rumored big A is true it gossip girl all over again.