In "It Happened 'That Night'," after the disappearance of Alison's body, Emily meets with Toby at the Brew. He tells her that he is remodeling the loft above the Brew, so he can live there for free.
In "Stolen Kisses," Wren meets Hanna at the Brew and tells her that Mona is to be relocated to another facility in New York.
In "A is for A-L-I-V-E," Ezra enters the shop. Aria is sitting at a table behind him and makes schoolwork, and when she sees him, she gets up and wants to go - as if she had not seen him. Mr. Fitz noted, however, that Aria is here and speaks to her. They talk about the situation and their relationship to Aria said goodbye to him and calls him "Mr. Fitz".
In "Turn of the Shoe" the girls are talking at the brew about The Black Widow and Melissa while Spencer sets up a diagram of the night of the lodge fire with everyone's food. Mona comes in, apologizing for being late, and talking about the Ali situation. Hanna accuses her of putting Ashley's phone in Wilden's casket and the liars stand up from the table and take Hanna's side. All five girls leave the Brew to head to the RV lair where Mona wants to prove herself as loyal to the liars.
In "Under The Gun," Aria meets Connor (Mike's friend and new employee at The Brew) and offers him some help with his English paper. Emily is put in charge of an Open Mic Night at The Brew and places adverts around town including the police station. During the Open Mic Night Connor's car is smashed with a baseball bat and spray-painted with the word "LIAR" by someone in a Sharks hoodie. Shana performs at the Open Mic Night on her violin.
Employees of The Brew
- The shop's name is a nod to the Alfred Hitchcock movie "Rear Window," one of many allusions to Hitchcock films made throughout the PLL series.
- This is where Zack and Ella meet.
- The Liars meet CeCe Drake at The Brew.
- Aria met Connor at The Brew.
- The Liars frequently meet at The Brew.
- In Season 5, Ezra bought the Brew, and turned it into a book store and coffee shop.