|“||I figured now that you're starting a family of your own that... It would be a good time to make amends.||”|
— Jenna to Toby
Their relationship is extremely tempestuous, especially due to the fact that Jenna pursued and blackmailed Toby into entering a sexual relationship with her during their younger years.
Jenna: There is nothing wrong with us, Toby. We're not really related.
Jenna: Do you like my costume?
Toby: It's nice. But you know... [he covers her one eyes so she can't see] I liked you better like this.
Jenna: I figured now that you're starting a family of your own that... It would be a good time to make amends.
Toby: Yeah? I remember we tried that about three years ago and it didn't go so well.
Jenna: Yeah, maybe not. But I would really like to try again.
Marco: Not sure how much threat a blind girl can be.
Toby: You haven't met Jenna.
Jenna: Toby? I know this may seem weird, but... I don't think Spencer's-Spencer.